Understanding Google Local Search Ads, Google Ads, and Google Business Profiles: Which One is Right for Your Business?

If you’re looking to market your business online, you’ve probably heard of Google Local Search Ads (LSAs), Google Ads, and Google Business Profiles (formerly Google Maps or Google My Business). The confusion surrounding these terms is common, but understanding their differences can significantly impact how you promote your business effectively on Google.

In this guide, we’ll break down these key digital marketing tools, explaining how each works, their advantages, and how they fit into a well-rounded marketing strategy.

What Are Google Local Search Ads (LSAs)?

Google Local Search Ads, also known as Google Guaranteed ads, appear at the top of search results when someone looks for a service in their area. These ads are labeled as “Google Guaranteed,” signifying that Google has vetted and approved the businesses listed.

How LSAs Work

Businesses must apply and pass Google’s verification process, which includes background checks and licensing requirements.
LSAs operate on a pay-per-lead model, meaning you are only charged when a potential customer contacts you via the ad.
Google determines the cost per lead, which can range from $35 to over $100, depending on the industry and location.

Pros and Cons of LSAs

✅ Pros:

Prime visibility at the top of search results.
Pay only for actual leads, not just clicks.
Builds trust with Google’s verification badge.

❌ Cons:

Requires extensive approval and documentation.
Lead costs are determined by Google and may be high.
Limited control over ad customization.

Google Ads: The Traditional Pay-Per-Click (PPC) Option

Google Ads are another set of paid results. Unlike LSAs, Google Ads operate on a pay-per-click (PPC) model, meaning businesses are charged each time someone clicks their ad.

How Google Ads Work

Businesses create ads targeting specific keywords.
Ads link to landing pages where potential customers can learn more or take action.
The cost per click (CPC) varies based on competition and industry, sometimes reaching $50+ per click.

Pros and Cons of Google Ads

✅ Pros:

Full control over ad copy, offers, and landing pages.
Can be optimized for conversions to lower cost per lead.
Allows precise targeting by location, keyword, audience, and device.

❌ Cons:

Requires ongoing management and optimization.
Costs can add up if not properly optimized.
Clicks don’t guarantee leads—conversion strategy is essential.

Google Business Profile (Formerly Google Maps or Google My Business)

Google Business Profiles, commonly known as Google Maps Listings, is a free tool from Google that enables businesses to manage their online presence on Google Search and Maps. It serves as a digital storefront that makes it easier for customers to find and engage with businesses.

How Google Business Profiles Work

Businesses create a profile, listing essential details like hours, services, and contact information.
Customers can leave reviews, and Google uses these to determine ranking in the local search pack.
The ranking is influenced by proximity, relevance, and review quality.

Pros and Cons of Google Business Profiles

✅ Pros:

Completely free and highly visible in local search results.
Helps build credibility through customer reviews.
Can drive substantial leads without paid ads.

❌ Cons:

No guaranteed ranking—Google determines placement based on factors like reviews and engagement.
Limited control over what Google prioritizes in search results.

Organic Search Results: SEO and Long-Term Visibility

Below Google Business Profiles, you’ll find the organic search results, which are based on search engine optimization (SEO). Ranking in organic results requires optimizing your website’s content, structure, and authority to increase visibility.

How SEO Works

Websites that provide valuable content and a great user experience rank higher.
Google considers factors like page load speed, keyword relevance, backlinks, and mobile-friendliness.
SEO is a long-term strategy but can generate significant free traffic over time.

Pros and Cons of SEO

✅ Pros:

No direct advertising costs.
Builds long-term credibility and traffic.
Can capture high-intent searches.

❌ Cons:

Takes time and effort to rank.
Requires ongoing optimization.
Rankings can fluctuate based on algorithm updates.

The Best Strategy for Your Business

If you’re wondering which Google marketing strategy is best for your business, consider these factors:

1. Limited Budget? Start by optimizing your Google Business Profile since it’s free and can generate leads.
2. Need Immediate Results? Invest in Google Ads to drive targeted traffic to a landing page.
3. Looking for a Trust Badge? Apply for Google LSAs to leverage the credibility of Google Guaranteed.
4. Long-Term Growth? Implement an SEO strategy to build sustainable organic visibility.

Ideally, a well-rounded approach incorporates all four, ensuring your business appears in multiple places on Google. If a potential customer searches for a service you offer and sees your ad under LSAs, your Google Ad, your Business Profile, and your website in organic results, your chances of converting that lead increase significantly.

Final Thoughts

Marketing your business on Google doesn’t have to be confusing. By understanding LSAs, Google Ads, Google Business Profiles, and SEO, you can make informed decisions about where to invest your time and budget.

At the very least, ensure your Google Business Profile is fully optimized with updated information and reviews. Then, as your business grows, explore Google Ads and LSAs for paid visibility while working on an SEO strategy for long-term success.

Want to dive deeper into Digital Marketing Strategies?

Check out our Service Marketing Simplified course, where we break down these concepts in detail to help you grow your business.

LEARN MORE